WATCH: This Video Is A Shocking Commentary On American Intolerance (VIDEO)

In the summer of 2013, filmmaker Alli Coates, and performance artist Signe Pierce, made a short video of a “social experiment” they conducted, in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. The video is a shocking commentary on American intolerance, and fear of things that we cannot identify or categorize.

The video, called “American Reflexxx,” features Pierce, dressed in what Coates calls “stripper attire,” and a reflective mask, walking around the streets of Myrtle Beach. People begin to take notice, and, while most offer a look, or a comment, and move on, a small crowd develops, following her around. There is a good deal of dialog amongst the crowd, about whether Pierce is a man or a woman. “That’s a dude!” can be heard a number of times. It is obvious that some of the onlookers are disturbed by their inability to see Pierce’s face. One man says, “Your body bad, but I can’t tell what you look like until I see your face.”

As the 14-minute video progresses, some in the crowd become more aggressive towards Pierce. Things are thrown at her. A woman runs into the picture, and shoves Pierce from behind, knocking her to the ground. The crowd surrounds her as she lies on the ground, but only one man even attempts to see if she is alright, and even he doesn’t try to help her up. Some call for him to take off her mask. Eventually, Pierce sits up, gathers her things, and resumes walking down the street, with the crowd in tow. If you think that intolerance is dying out with older Americans, think again. The crowd that follows Pierce is made up of mostly young people.

Director Coates describes “American Reflexxx” as “[A] heart wrenching technicolor spectacle that raises questions about gender stereotypes, mob mentality, and violence in America.” It is a disturbing commentary on American society, and our reactions to things that are different, unusual, or that make us uncomfortable in some way.

Here is “American Reflexxx,” via YouTube (Caution: Strong language)


Featured image via YouTube screen capture

  • Mike

    So who doesn’t realize that young people are as stupid and bigoted as their elders?

    • FastMovingCloud

      Especially in South Carolina!!

      • D Toole

        Actually, for the most part (other than in this video), I find the young people in SC slightly more tolerant than in other Southern states. Tennessee and Georgia are really, really bad.

  • Rick Derris

    I couldn’t get through the first 1:30 of that video. It kept scrambling like it was one of the more violent scenes in a Saw movie.

  • Bjorn Sodergren

    Who ever edited that video should be shot in the eye.

    • Curt

      Interesting violent reaction.

  • Kathy Mulholland-Isabell

    So disturbing. The violence, the hate. OMG.

  • JoJoViolet

    Sure there was some rudeness and some hate but I also saw curiosity and a whole lot of folks that knew it was a performance of some kind. All the ‘make way for the camera lady’ and the crowd following her. It was being filmed and they knew it. Now I knew it was a performance and I wasn’t sure the push to the ground was real or staged to see the reaction, still don’t.
    My point. The mask and the visible camera gave away that it was an act of some kind so the reactions are not necessarily realistic either. If two guys dressed as wild west cowboys with gun belts and side arms walked into the street like they were going to duel it out quick draw style, AND there was a camera guy filming, would people run in fear? Call the cops? Or get out their cell phones and start filming and cheering them on?

    • Angelgirl

      Nobody was messing with the guy in bloody makeup with the axe, I noticed. And that was clearly a performance as well.

      • Christopher Courter

        That guy works at a Ripley’s Haunted Attraction there in Myrtle Beach. He is always on the street trying to get people to pay to come inside.

    • Linda Martin

      If you couldn’t tell if that shove was real, you need some kind of help or new glasses. That porky little demon ran up and shoved her down, then the coward ran away. I hope they all see themselves in this video and see what a bunch of heathens they are. Will they care? Probably not.

    • Duckia

      This picture circulates on social media pretty regularly and it ought to answer your question pretty well:

  • Tiffany

    Wow. Some one violently shoved her, and no one bothered to help her. Act or not the shove was obviously not part of it. Those people are disgusting.

  • http://theauntiewarhol.wordpress.com/ Auntie Warhol

    “There is a good deal of dialog amongst the crowd, about whether Pierce is a man or a woman. “That’s a dude!” can be heard a number of times.”

    Welcome to every day for non-passing trans people.

  • Linda Martin

    First of all, what did they expect from the people of South Carolina? If she walked down the streets of New York City like that, no one would pay attention. …second of all……those people reminded me of a pack of wild animals. Just clap your shoes together to make a loud noise and they run away. That’s a perfect example of the pack mentality. The bigger the group got, the braver they got. That’s what happens in these riots. The more the merrier. The more the crazier.

    • Matthew Contey

      Correction: Maybe MOST of New York City would. As a native of the NYC area, I would not say that so definitively. Just because we might be more level-headed up North generally speaking, doesn’t mean ALL of us are.

  • Michael Corliss

    I will wait to see whether or not this was (largely) staged. It makes a point either way, but if staged, it becomes someone’s opinion of what might happen.

  • ChantDownBabylon

    interesting that black people seem less tolerant than the whites….

    • regroce

      Interesting to see that it was white woman who hit her from behind, too, huh? ….jackass…

    • Duckia

      Interesting that you failed to notice that the majority of people in the film were black, as many major cities of South Carolina are predominantly black. It seemed like a pretty mixed bag to me, seeing as how none of the black people assaulted ‘her’ physically. Regroce pointed out that a white woman pushed ‘her’, and I’ll point out that a white girl tried to trip ‘her’. Twice. And a couple of white boys with their pants half off were getting awfully close to ‘her.’ Pierce made quite the spectacle of himself in this documentary and it would appear to me that the “less tolerant black people” were merely being spectators.

    • nothingmusic42

      gee, the women that assaulted her looked awfully pale for black people…

  • Doug Williams

    what a disgusting commentary on society and the state of our youth!! which is why I prefer to stay home with my dog who has much better manners! what a pack Hyenas!

  • veronica Alleyne

    a man in a dress & high heels really isn’t that unique anymore

    • Duckia

      The problem with your way of thinking is that it IS rather unique in a place of South Carolina, even in a popular city like Myrtle Beach. If they shot this in Chicago, I would agree with you, as seeing men dressed in similar fashions is a regularly thing on Broadway in Boys Town. But it was not shot in Chicago; it may as well have been shot in southern Georgia for all of the hate and intolerance that the content displays.

    • rejectrepublicanlies

      In LA or New York maybe, but this would be considered a very provocative act in much of the country.

  • Efrain DeJesus

    That was no one else than Bruce Jenner!

  • Hal Whitlock

    This is billed as a “Commentary on American Intolerance.” Perhaps it should be titled as a “Commentary on Crowd Manipulation.” It is obvious the ‘masked lady’ of the video was out to garner as much attention as possible…and on the streets of Myrtle Beach at that! Keep in mind there is obviously a cameraman (or crew) following this ‘silver-masked’ girl’ as she walks/dances in an ultra-provocative way in a crowd of people. Yes, this will cause anyone to stand back and take notice. The attention seeking, silver-faced girl got exactly what she set out for…attention and comments from intoxicated men and women. Bottom line: The crowd was reacting exactly as the filmmaker anticipated, given the stimulus that was revealed to the crowd and in the way that it was revealed. Furthermore, film editing and dramatic effects are powerful tools to a filmmaker. Valid crowd responses and filmmaker credibility would be attained if 1) the editing didn’t contain so many effects to promote drama; 2) there were efforts taken to remove anything that would attract unnecessary attention (use of hidden camera and the absence of that silly mask). Unfortunately, none of these things were present.

    Clearly there is an agenda here…

    By the way, I am from the great state of South Carolina that so many of you called “Ignorant” and “Bigoted.” I am not a bigot, nor am I uneducated (I hold a Doctorate degree in Counseling by the way). I am curious as to why a South Carolinian is the only one to pick up on so many manipulations and inconsistencies in this faux commentary.

    • Duckia

      The simple fact that you are clearly missing is that the documentary was filmed to showcase the intolerance of the average (southern) American when presented with something they cannot fully understand. If Pierce had gone out dressed as a woman and showed his face as a man, it would not have held any sort of mystery; he would have been clearly identifiable as a man.
      I agree with you on many of your points in regards to the tourist ratio and perhaps a less obvious camera operator, but I disagree with “crowd manipulation.’ There was none of that going on. Neither the subject (Pierce) or his camera operator beckoned a crowd into forming. Neither one of them said anything to egg on any form of commentary from the crowd. Neither one of them suggested that they all follow Pierce around, throwing slurs and water bottles and attempted punches. Neither of them did anything to propel several of the girls in the crowd to try to rip of Pierce’s mask, or trip him, or successfully push him to the ground. There was no crowd manipulation. This is what happens in face of misunderstanding and intolerance.

      • Hal Whitlock

        I agree that the “bully” reaction was deplorable; however, intolerance is not synonymous with hatefulness. Someone can be intolerant of a certain lifestyle or life-choice and still show respect while being intolerant. This word has been used to rob people of their right to their belief and right of opinion, while stating the persons belief and opinions are fueled by hate. This is not true all of the time…and it is certainly not something that one area of the country has a monopoly on. To make a blanket statement of the “average southern American” being intolerant of something they can not understand, and then to imply ignorance is quite offensive. First of all, there is a far greater chance than not that the perpetrators in the video were NOT southern, and therefore NOT an “average southern American.” The video is, among other things, an attempt to degrade Southern Americans as ignorant and hateful…which is shameful. This video could have been filmed in any tourist spot, given the same stimulus, and it would have received the same reaction. The crowds reactions is not the result of intolerance, but rather the result of the lack of respect that is prevalent in this country. This lack of respect is evident on both sides of the camera, as far as I am concerned.

  • Lisa Brown Lundin

    Who are the women who tripped and pushed the performance artist down? There are people out there who know these women. I think their photos should be posted on Facebook so that everyone knows their character.

  • Blue M Perry

    the very obvious camera may have had an influence on the behavior as well, people acting up for a video, and knowing/believing that something is being staged.

  • Duckia

    Probably joining in, or turning a blind eye while a “freak” was the target. After all, the police are (probably, majorly) from South Carolina, too, and even further lack compassion and understand for humanity in its most unusual forms.

  • rejectrepublicanlies

    This was very disturbing. As I’ve always known: The mob rules. This is a generation of thugs and folks that lack empathy for others. By the way, Bruce Jenner, congratulations on your transition, just please remember that you back a party that hates and discriminates against trans gender people, gays and lesbians. Finally, this is a good reason be armed or able to defend yourself.

  • lugnut

    I saw a lot of evil in these people. Barbarians. This person is greater than them all. Now can you see how humans are more than capable in treating other humans like this throughout history. Well humans haven’t changed at all, This person actually showed more humanity than any of them.

  • lugnut

    Clear the beach of the scum that’s left behind, they are not deserving. They act like a pack of demons.

  • Trevor Grover

    what do you expect from south carolina?

  • Rajam Roose

    It’s the mask that makes the horror. If the person wasn’t wearing the reflective mask, there wouldn’t be quite so much obvious drama. People feel comfortable mocking and taunting a mask. Try that experiment without the mask………..I can bet there wouldn’t be so much interest.

    Humans can develop a mob mentality…….but what is so fascinating is that they can also develop a group mentality to help one another. The line is so fine between the two.

    • Cthulhu

      The mask was the point. Way to miss it.

      • Rajam Roose

        The point was not missed. Research shows that we need to see a face in order to feel empathy for another human being. Without the face, there is no empathy. Our brains will do that in other ways even if the person isn’t wearing a mask.

        • Elizabeth

          Well since it was reflective, I assumed it’s meant to show those who are reacting to this…and it certainly isn’t a pretty picture.

  • Sandra Schomberg

    this was hard to watch. the shameful behavior, the taunting and finally the attack by the cowardly female. the only difference between her and many of the people around her was the mask. many were dressed just as provocatively. she was very brave (even with a photographer with her) many of these people were scary and she was finally attacked. this is the dirty side of America folks, many see it every day.

  • Susan Ava

    It would’ve been more powerful wo the stupid sound & visual effects.
    But wow, a real look at humans as primates. Watch how troop of chimps react to a stranger and you can see we’re not as highly evolved as we think. All it takes is one weird person to turn a crowd into a mob. Hope some of those idiots saw this and had the decency to be ashamed of themselves.

  • Alichia

    There is a theory that people tend not to like a person because they see something in that person that they don’t like about themselves. It’s that part they try to keep hidden, which they do behind a metaphorical mask. The anger could be coming from a place that they are hiding within, and having to face her and her mirrored mask means seeing their reflection. Now they feel their metaphorical mask had been stripped off, causing a feeling of nakedness, embarrassment, and fear. Anger ensues within and now all they want to do is break the mirror. They think this tactic will shield their insecurities, even if it’s at the expense of another’s well-being.

  • CaitR

    This was def one of the weirdest videos I have watched. I could not believe it when the woman tried to trip her..twice! And for that other woman to come from behind and violently shove her?? Disgusting. That woman should be found and brought up on charges! She could have been seriously hurt and no one was doing anything to help her.

    • CaitR

      I don’t know who CaitR is…I am def not her…

  • Bonnie Lee

    No need to subject people to this to prove how awful they are. We already know. This is absolutely no surprise to me having lived in SC for 20 years. The level of hate of anything thats different is alive and well here. :(

  • http://davidduke.com/ David Duke 2016

    They should have killed that freak.

    • 1ofmanyfriends1

      Have you no ability to read and understand what this is all about?
      You are the epitome of ignorant, uneducated white trash. And yes, I am sure that avatar IS your picture.

    • Adam

      and somewhere some one has said the same about you

      • http://davidduke.com/ David Duke 2016

        I shoot first and don’t ask questions you piece of sh!t.

        • Adam

          you honestly think you matter to anyone in this world…let my laugh harder at how little you really know, and let me say it in language you will understand. eat a bullet you pig f**king back of d**ks

      • http://davidduke.com/ David Duke 2016

        Post your address coward. We can settle this in person you commie piece of sh!t.

        • Adam

          omg you actually are serious, let me laugh harder at your ignorance

  • Fablespinner

    The violence all starts with the same woman. She’s the first to try to run into her, first to throw water, then to trip her shoes up, until finally she runs up behind and pushes her. It takes only one determined person to create a mob scene of violence and intolerance.

  • Wonderer

    Tourist town worst of the worst in Americans. In the south also that has a tradition of intolerance. I have worked overseas now for almost a decade. I come back to the US maybe once a year I have really noticed the hate and intolerance growing, sad and scary. Whats to become of my native country.

  • 1ofmanyfriends1

    It was FAR more than just a few kids… many of those following her and saying repulsive things were adults. The woman who violently pushed her down then ran away (SO brave!!) is well into her thirties.
    As far as SC being backwards, YES IT IS, as are many parts of the South. Take a couple of these people and place them in an upscale restaurant in New York City to see how unrefined and downright uncivil they are. They would be SO out of place they would feel like the person in the video with the exception that NONE of the patrons of the restaurant would treat her like this.
    And BTW, that would be ‘take exception to’…..

  • Adam

    no your dogs would get mad that you were cheating on them wouldn’t they not to mention your sister/daughter/son

  • http://davidduke.com/ David Duke 2016

    You’re a coward as well as a communist socialist homosexual. You should be lynched.

    • Adam

      says the moron with the private profile

  • http://davidduke.com/ David Duke 2016

    God hates ni99ers and so do I. Praise God!

  • Adam

    dont you all just hate when you step in some dog crap and the smell just will not go away, you spray your shoe with a hose you use some body spray and all you can smell is that crap on your shoe, sorry about the tangent but something just made me wonder, something i just cant put my finger on.