West Virginia Man Claims Teaching Evolution Hampers Daughter’s Veterinary Dreams; Sues State Dept. of Ed.

In the fruit basket of dangerous and wrong-headed ideas that the religious right has served the United States with since the 1970s, Creationism is probably the least dangerous, especially when compared with real social threat of climate change denialism and anti-vaxxers.

Which isn’t to say that creationism doesn’t harm society; it does. And an example of that comes from West Virginia, where a man is suing the state Department of Education for teaching his daughter — who wants to become a veterinarian — evolution.

Learning physics without learning Newton

Evolution is the corner-stone of modern biology. Without evolution, there is no biology.

This is what makes the lawsuit filed by Kenneth Smith so confusing. Smith’s daughter has dreams of being a veterinarian, which means having a solid grounding in biology.

Yet, Smith is of the mind that teaching evolution is a violation of the Constitution and the civil rights of his daughter. According to the “Charleston Daily Mail,” Smith believes that by teaching evolution, school officials are “propagating” a “religion.”

From the lawsuit:

Their actions during the 2014-2015 school year affects my child’s future directly through the state grading system to enter college and the ability to earn economic security and a good job in her chosen veterinarian medical field of work, by being taught a faith base (evolutionary ideology) that just doesn’t exist and has no math to back it.

According to his lawyer, Smith filed the suit in the Northern District of West Virginia on May 12, and is suing everyone from the state Superintendent to the United States Secretary of Education Arne Duncan.

Learning biology without learning evolution, while theoretically possible, is like learning mechanical physics without learning Newton. It doesn’t matter how much you learn, if you don’t accept the basics, you’re not moving anywhere.


Featured image via Wikimedia Commons

  • Theoldlady

    Get over it, Evolution is a belief system that never happened.There is no math to back it up! All simply theories.

    • http://miasews.blogspot.com/ Bastetsmom

      I hope that’s sarcasm….

      • Theoldlady

        Do you believe in evolution? Or do you have faith in the evolution theory? Do you have math to back it up? Then prove it.

        • Charlie3

          The very existence of people like you who are incapable of critical thinking poses a clear and present danger to this country.

          • Theoldlady

            I am very critical of people trying to prove something like evolution without the facts to back it up. I present no danger at all to this country or any other country. There are plenty of folks who simply do not believe in evolution for it has not been proven as a fact.

        • Charlie3

          You were just told that Biology contains the math to prove that evolution is a fact and not a theory, but you obviously have been bamboozled beyond redemption.

          • Theoldlady

            Prove it with the facts. I do not need any redemption, just the math facts.

          • Lawrence Tyler

            Name then the universal set that correlates with God’s existence.

    • DaddyO_969

      I sincerely hope you’re joking.

    • DaddyO_969

      The statement ‘simply theories’ makes it clear that you have neither the education nor the understanding of the concept to offer an opinion.
      Certainly the math exists, it’s called BIOLOGY. And the are examples everywhere you look. There’re even example of forced evolution all around.

      • Theoldlady

        Biology does not prove evolution. I can offer my opinion any time I want to and need no ok from you. The math does not exist.I studied biology and it does not prove evolution. There are indeed scientists who have monkeyed with cells and created what they call their proof for evolution. Some have admitted to doing the monkeying around trying to prove evolution. So DaddyO get off my case and prove what you say.

  • http://miasews.blogspot.com/ Bastetsmom

    If that guy wants to waste his money it’s okay with me.

    • ruth ferguson

      Yes that would be nice except for How that would effect the daughter. She no doubt needs her father’s money to pay for her education.
      I honestly don’t see the conflict. Fundamentalists wear me out.

  • Adam

    annnnnnd i have a migrane from the stupidity

    • Theoldlady

      Me too.

  • Sunwyn Ravenwood

    Do you ever just want to get a 2 x 4 and knock on these people’s heads until they come to their senses?

  • Jinmichigan

    More frivolousness lawsuits from the right, Who’s surprised?

  • Michael Schiller

    If the school where his Daughter is being educated for her chosen field teaches the theory of evolution as a means to an end, the Daughter has options. !) go to another school. 2) Chose another field. 3) tolerate a new theory. One you might not agree with, but it is a means to an end. 4) Dump your Father. He is not well considering the facts and time lines. Enjoy a successful life, on your own terms Daughter.

  • Theoldlady

    Now that I got your attention, there can be no evolution for evolution does not support the ‘seed after seed’ and ‘kind after kind’ as it is explained in the bible. I do believe there were millions of people on this earth before there was Adam and Eve and in fact millions and millions of years of animals and humans on this earth before Adam and Eve. And so that is the way I teach it in my bible study lessons. But ‘seed after seed’ and ‘kind after kind’ is just the way it is. Just try mixing the kind after kind and seeds after seeds and see what happens.

    • ruth ferguson

      Yes. You get a new variety of whatever. One year a volunteer very small watermelon thrived in my garden. Except as it matured, it took on a rougher skin, still striped like a watermelon, b but more tan than green. When ripe and cut open it was pink and tasted like cantelope. Previous year I had both in garden so they obviously cross pollinated.
      Now if you’re talking about a sheep and cattle, no not possible (that I know of).

      • Theoldlady

        So did you plant any of those seeds and if so what happened?

        • ruth ferguson

          I matured and dried, kept some seeds but we moved from farm, no garden area, lost the seeds as time passed.