Is This A Circle? Psychologists Claim Your Answer May Reveal Something Surprising

Meet a new friend? Curious about a co-worker’s political leaning? According to a study published by the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology a person’s answer to this question can tell you whether they are liberal or conservative.

Is this a circle?

According to the study, if a person says, “yes,” they are more likely to be liberal. It is said they are more likely to support social programs like help for the homeless, unemployment benefits, welfare, food stamps and are more likely to support things like marriage equality and legalization of recreational marijuana.

If a person says, “no,” they are more than likely politically conservative. Accordingly, it is probable that they will support things like having a strong military and protecting the rights of business owners. Additionally it says they are more likely to have strong views opposing illegal immigration and strongly condemn even lower-level crimes like drug offenses and prostitution.

The Guardian published an article which stated:

People who are tolerant of deviance from the norm when judging a circle (or triangle, square, rectangle or ellipse) are tolerant of deviant or otherwise marginalised groups in society. In fact, they’re not just tolerant of these groups, they actively want to help them.

Truth be told, I must not be as strong of a liberal as I thought, because my immediate response was “technically, that’s not a circle because math.”

But, I digress, my bleeding heart is still bleeding.

What did you think? Is it a circle?


Featured image via The Guardian

 

  • Henry Schump

    It’s a circle, with a few modifications it can be perfect.

  • Jeannine Green Brewer

    It’s not a mathematically perfect circle, no. But it begins and ends at the same point, like a hiking trail, so let’s
    call it a loop.

    • Jackie Parshall

      Lol, a loop is not a circle but I applaud your peace making skills. Compromise is a good thing.

      • Jeannine Green Brewer

        Thank you.

  • Jackie Parshall

    I agree, not a circle, because you are right, math. I am however, a bleeding heart liberal and proud of it.

  • Teale

    Yes it is a circle, just like I’m a human being, not perfect but still a human being and a bleeding heart liberal.

    • nowhereman

      It seems like we’re bleeding a lot more lately.

  • sara

    If the directions say “Draw a circle around…” this is the shape you are likely to get. It’s a circle, just not a perfect one.

    • justsaying

      there is no other type of circle. All circles by definition are perfect. circle - a round plane figure whose boundary (the circumference) consists of points equidistant from a fixed point (the center).

      • Seth Fox

        Splitting hairs on a circle? It’s a circle, literally. But it’s hardly perfect drawn and we all can see that.

  • theseditionist

    From the ‘what can we politicize now’ department…

  • Bruce Brown

    Thats just stupid. Ask a three year old. They will tell you thats a circle. They don’t have a political view yet.

    • zelduh

      Three year olds have not have enough time to absorb the “conservative” ideology. Give them a few more years of programming by their ammosexual and hypochristian parents… 😉

  • Jim Tatman

    Not a circle, but I’m a Liberal Democrat.

  • Danyel Hoskins

    Not a circle, math says so, but I am extremely liberal so I guess they are wrong on many counts.

  • Bloodysot

    I answered to myself “yes, it is a circle, just not a regular circle”

    • zelduh

      Exactly what I did too.

  • Otto Greif

    If you stare at it long enough it becomes 3D.

  • capt.carl

    The hypotheses is so frickin’ wrong - and I must ask what does the Authors procreation prowess have to do with this stand ?? any learned person will call this unbroken line a circle because it does have a radius - no corners - etc. etc. and I am not a liberal by any measure of the word - nada - I am a very docile and tolerant individual who enjoys cooking and puzzles of many types - I am also in agreement with Stephen Hawkins - the most complicated puzzle he has yet to tackle is ‘women’ and he’s on his fourth marriage - that dog. It’s a circle! Now go fornicate something…

  • Jerry Adkins

    To say this is not a circle is to say, there is no such thing as a circle because there is no such thing as a perfect circle.

  • my5cents

    It is sort of a circle but not a perfect circle. The shape itself is circular, but most circles do not have bumps and lumps in them.

    • IxoIII

      Didn’t ask if it was a “perfect” circle, just “is this a circle”. How could one answer no?

  • IxoIII

    Of course it’s a circle. If someone drew that and asked anyone what it was, the person would say “circle”.

    Trump/Cruz ’16.

  • Barry Milburn

    I’m as liberal as they come and I answered that was not a circle. I guess my perfectionist side came out on this one!

  • nowhereman

    It’s definitely a circle. It’s just not a perfect circle.

  • Greuvey

    Sort of…it is a continuous line in the general shape of a circle. However, it’s sloppy and the drawer needs practice! I say that makes me a moderate with liberal leanings! 😉

  • Sheila Rivera

    I thought yes it’s mostly a circle. I would consider it a circle but could see why other’s might not consider it one. I seem to be going around in circles…I know I couldn’t stop myself.

  • Lacey Christian

    If it’s not a circle then what is it? A triangle?

  • Fred McCoy

    my immediate reaction was yes, It’s imperfect but still a circle.

  • justsaying

    it’s not a circle. it’s a circular object. The definition of a circle: a round plane figure whose boundary (the circumference) consists of points equidistant from a fixed point (the center).

    I don’t buy the article’s premise. On one hand i can understand the idea that someone willing to accept this as a circle might be more inclusive if it wasn’t for something called EDUCATION. Because of education, I am a former math teacher and a very, extremely, liberal person. Education opened my mind to new ideas and the fact that a circle is a mathematical construct and must fit the mathematical definition. Although there are educated conservatives, they are also so many “educated” conservatives that believe in creationism. That tends to make me believe education is not very strong in the conservative world.

    The belief in evolution, supported by much science, is not a requirement of liberalism. But a belief in a scientific explanation that has abundant science backing it up, is. Creationism or Intelligent design do not pass for a scientific belief.

  • Philip Benson

    It Is not a perfect oval.

  • Bradford Marston

    BUT…..what if pretty much everyone did not see that the image “could have also been” an aerial photograph looking straight down on a large group of my friends, all wearing black hats and clothes, standing on a large white surface, and told to form a large circle. Sure, they may not have formed a perfect circle, but they would most certainly still be my “CIRCLE” of friends, right?

    Mathematicians… liberal or conservative, how do y’all respond to that? Just thought I’d throw in a little “outside the box” perspective to rattle a few cages….and provide some food for thought for everyone with a singular view on the question. I feel if we, business owners, our representatives in offices across the country and other leaders started looking for more perspectives many of our problems would quickly disappear…..

  • drklassen

    Or, they’re a stickler for definition when they know that being a stickler doesn’t cause societal harm. It’s NOT A CIRCLE!

  • mikenstl

    My answer depends on who drew it, if it was a 6 yr. old, someone with muscle control problems, even by someone in a hurry, I’d say sure, close enough, it’s a circle, if it was the circle drawing utility in photoshop… Then I’d say definitely not a circle. And yes I’m proud to say that I am a liberal too… Lol

  • Martin

    Sort of? It could be construed as an orbital path?

  • https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100008226816244 SinDelle Morte

    What I found most interesting was that the author took her results to mean she is not as liberal as thought, rather than declaring the test is obviously inaccurate.

    Don’t let other people tell you who you are.